eThoughts : May 1, 2009: Conflict
The mark of civility cannot be solely measured by our ability to be courteous and considerate to others, but must include the ability to handle conflict in a constructive manner. In fact, if we can do that, the rest comes naturally. What most of us do much of the time is to practice being courteous and considerate—and mostly tolerant. So it should come as no great surprise that we’re better at tolerating people than we are at handling conflict.
That’s why we’re not really a civil species.
Since conflict cannot always be avoided—and shouldn’t be—we have to have methods to deal with it. The usual strategy is to win. However, that’s not my definition of a constructive handling of trouble, that’s my definition of losing. And here’s why: winning as a conflict resolution is not doing one’s best. That’s a loss. And having losers and winners is a loss. Sure, sometimes we’ve got to lay down the law, but even the necessary use of authority is not a win, it just a necessary use of force. Something went wrong.
Did that stick in your craw? I can see the people from Wall Street to Main Street, from Washington DC to the mayor of Podunk, USA, from the racketeers to the religious, from generals to privates, thinking about how political naiveté can kill position and render us vulnerable. Guess why that’s true: It’s because we’ve made it true, not because it’s an inherent truth. It’s born of the belief that it’s a dog-eat-dog world and one better get the biggest bowl and guard it like crazy.
It’s funny how much we want to distance ourselves from the animal kingdom, yet follow many of those same the-strongest-will-survive laws. Yet, as Cesar Milan of Dog Whisperer fame said, we’re the only species that will follow an emotionally unstable leader. Besides, the notion that the strongest will survive is a human interpretation of the animal kingdom. Another way to look at it is the strongest will set the order in the interest of cooperation—nutsos are not good for the order, or cooperation. Certainly putting people down is not about the good of the order, it’s about gaining personal power and standing. But challenging nutty ideas and/or authority when we need clarity is mostly appropriate, as long as we’re not in crisis mode—as in immediate personal danger from this nuttiness.
Look, we’re different people with different attentions. We don’t get stuff at the same time or necessarily in the same way—or at all. This state of affairs is natural, like a temporal displacement. For example, feedback from taste is not on the same temporal plane as feedback from our digestive system. It isn’t about one of these winning out, it’s about knowing the displacement exists and dealing with it. That knowing could help us to not eat or drink so much so fast. Understanding temporal displacements might help in other areas as well, such as love. And it will certainly help with general interpersonal relationships, which would help with cultural and global relationships. It is not so important that we’re all on the same page, it is important that we’re not at each other’s throats.
And here’s the real point: It’s important that we don’t avoid conflict as a compass heading. In fact, I say we engage in it. Where civility comes into real play is when we practice civil conflict—as in going after getting the reality right, as opposed to going after being right.
What is civil conflict? For one thing, we need to quit taking things personally. If we’re wrong, we’re wrong. If we’re right, we’re right. If we are mostly wrong, we’ve got some learning to do. If we’re mostly right, there’s still stuff we’re probably missing—one can fix something that isn’t broken, as in making it better. In any case, cooperation is much more likely to spawn commitment, and civil conflict is more likely to inoculate against exclusivity. We need to correctly do both cooperation and conflict to really engage in civility.
So, in the interest of true civility and cooperation, let’s have a good fight, let’s wonder about what the hell someone means or what they’re up to or why they stole those clothes from a homeless person or why they think they’re the only normal one in the Star War’s Bar. Then we just might get something done other than extending tolerance as a social construct or conflict as a tool to stamp out all the “crazies.” Heck, maybe we’ll even experience acceptance. I’m willing to bet we’d actually breathe easier and have energy for something other than looking over our shoulders. In short, let’s really interact. That doesn’t mean we’ve got to pour our hearts out and show our scars, it means use the context, not our pre-planned way of saying and interacting and living. And let’s accept that we’re all fools, and that that state of affairs doesn’t mean we are without dignity.
Hmmm, maybe I should go first—and last, eh? :)
- By Travis Gibbs
- on May, 01, 2009
- eThoughts
- No Comments.
Recent Thoughts
- April 2, 2024: A Very Partial Story of an Old Man in the Woods in the Midst of Life’s Transient Things
- March, 1, 2024: Wisdom is Not a Singular Category
- February 1, 2024: Today’s Hunter-Gatherer Hunts for Information
- January 1, 2024: Hijacked: Time for a New Year
- December 1, 2023: Learning, Biology, Communication, Technology, Energy, and Alchemy
- November 1, 2023: Pre- and Post-Traumatic Stress
- October 1, 2023: When Language Becomes an Altar Instead of an Exchange
- September 1, 2023: No Wretch We Be (The Rant Continues)
- August 1, 2023: Magnifique! The In-Between Scene
- July 1, 2023: Intimacy Disorder: Humanities’ Adoption of Unrealistic Fear (so far)
- June 1, 2023: Integrative-Self Disorder and Integrative-Civil Disorder
- May 1, 2023: The Big Pretend
- April 2, 2023: Inflammation
- March 1, 2023: The Premise-Check Light is On: The Simple Life Myth
- February 1, 2023: Divine Mischief, Love, and Happiness
Stream of Consciousness
What people are saying
- Travis Gibbs on April 2, 2020: A Very Partial Story of Janis May
- Queenofchaos06 on April 2, 2020: A Very Partial Story of Janis May
- Travis Gibbs on November 1, 2019: The Trouble with Civility, Part II
- Edgar on November 1, 2019: The Trouble with Civility, Part II
- Travis Gibbs on July 1, 2019: Stoical in a Time of General Sorrow?
- Edgar on July 1, 2019: Stoical in a Time of General Sorrow?
- Edgar on January 31, 2019: Mind Hack: Part Deux (see the blog dated December 10, 2016)
- Travis Gibbs on January 31, 2019: Mind Hack: Part Deux (see the blog dated December 10, 2016)
- Edgar on January 31, 2019: Mind Hack: Part Deux (see the blog dated December 10, 2016)
- Travis Gibbs on April 29, 2018: A World of Full of Intersections
- Edgar on April 29, 2018: A World of Full of Intersections
- Travis Gibbs on March 26, 2018: Part IV: Courage
- Edgar on March 26, 2018: Part IV: Courage
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- arianamromero on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on July 17, 2016: Making American Great Again? Telling it like it is?
- deborahdearest on July 17, 2016: Making American Great Again? Telling it like it is?
- Travis Gibbs on June 10, 2016: The Ratings Phenomenon
- adamgc91 on June 10, 2016: The Ratings Phenomenon
- Travis Gibbs on June 7, 2016: Who Can Use the Toilet?
- Immune2Tasers on June 7, 2016: Who Can Use the Toilet?
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- ndelao on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on June 3, 2014: God and Machine
- actions on June 3, 2014: God and Machine
- Travis Gibbs on September 9, 2013: The Not Even Ready for Bumper-Sticker Philosophy
- Travis Gibbs on More Same Ol’, Same Ol’: November 25, 2013
- Lyla on More Same Ol’, Same Ol’: November 25, 2013
- Lyla on September 9, 2013: The Not Even Ready for Bumper-Sticker Philosophy
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- Megan TLe on Contact
- Megan TLe on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- Megan TLe on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on Renewal: One : Chasing Our Tails
- Travis Gibbs on More Caring and Less Carrying?: Political Diversions, Part II
- v1felipe on More Caring and Less Carrying?: Political Diversions, Part II
- v1felipe on Contact
- eThoughts: Freedom, Choice, and Enlightenment on Renewal The Non-Ordinary Reference Pages
- eThoughts: Holidays, Good Will, Genuineness, Control, Awareness, Love, Grace, and Experience | Travisgibbs.com on eThoughts : We Are and the Age of Clarity
- eThoughts: Freedom, Choice, and Enlightenment | Travisgibbs.com on Renewal Six : Choice Eventually Limits Choice
- Nice on Renewal: One : Chasing Our Tails