eThoughts : Journeying in Purgatorio
Recently I saw a television program about a dog kennel licensed by the government to buy and sell dogs—which they did, buying mostly from suspect sources and selling mostly to researchers. This particular kennel was being targeted by an animal rights group for abuses to the dogs. Indeed, the video footage presented reminded me of human death camps, only this time populated by canines.
After the evidence was turned over to authorities (it took months of undercover work to gather this evidence), it would be about another four years before the kennel was closed and fines were levied. And those convictions were not a slam dunk, looking like the process could fall apart many times. At the end of the program, with some issues like jail time still pending, the person who went undercover seemed a bit ambivalent—yes, finally a center for abusing animals was closed, but it was only one of many.
A class and my one-time reading of Dante’s The Divine Comedy does not make me a scholar, but as I recall, the nature of Inferno was that individuals knew there was something wrong, but had no other clues. In Purgatorio, people knew something was wrong and why, but had little or no idea how to correct the problems. In Paradiso, one knew how to correct problems. However, to “ascend” to Paradiso, one did not change either Inferno or Purgatorio, one learned how to navigate the landscape so they were not trapped. In effect, to enter Paradiso, one learned that something was wrong, why it was wrong, exactly what to do to right it, and finally, one put into practice what they had learned. Though Paradiso itself could change, along with the individuals in Paradiso, Inferno and Purgatorio could not change. The population of Paradiso attempted to help those in the other two levels to learn, which those individuals could possibly do, but there was no changing the essence of those two lower levels.
We can battle with the political, religious, philosophical/psychological structures on the planet, but that may be an exercise in futility. Was it Winston Churchhill who said that all politics are local? In life as we know it on this planet, it is not the big causes that will likely bear fruit, but the intra and interpersonal ones. It is acts of true civility, of true consideration, within and between each other that will enable us to change.
If we are looking for a noble quest, perhaps we might realize there is some measure of the greatness of the human heart and mind when we practice civility and consideration. Though I’m leaving out operational definitions of civility and consideration at this point, I suggest that both provide the best environment for learning and growing. So rather than fighting faceless structures, we might be better off polishing our hearts and minds and fine-tuning what we emphasize. When we speak and act with civility and consideration to ourselves and others, as opposed to emphasizing fears, or scarcity, or lack, or promises of what ifs, we are engaged in the noble journey, one that is not about undoing structure, but one that creates the engagements and corridors necessary for the living to breathe, roam, wonder, interact or not, and develop in their own time and space. Sugary sweet as it may sound, how better can we honor freedom?
- By Travis Gibbs
- on Jan, 20, 2006
- eThoughts
- No Comments.
Recent Thoughts
- April 2, 2024: A Very Partial Story of an Old Man in the Woods in the Midst of Life’s Transient Things
- March, 1, 2024: Wisdom is Not a Singular Category
- February 1, 2024: Today’s Hunter-Gatherer Hunts for Information
- January 1, 2024: Hijacked: Time for a New Year
- December 1, 2023: Learning, Biology, Communication, Technology, Energy, and Alchemy
- November 1, 2023: Pre- and Post-Traumatic Stress
- October 1, 2023: When Language Becomes an Altar Instead of an Exchange
- September 1, 2023: No Wretch We Be (The Rant Continues)
- August 1, 2023: Magnifique! The In-Between Scene
- July 1, 2023: Intimacy Disorder: Humanities’ Adoption of Unrealistic Fear (so far)
- June 1, 2023: Integrative-Self Disorder and Integrative-Civil Disorder
- May 1, 2023: The Big Pretend
- April 2, 2023: Inflammation
- March 1, 2023: The Premise-Check Light is On: The Simple Life Myth
- February 1, 2023: Divine Mischief, Love, and Happiness
Stream of Consciousness
What people are saying
- Travis Gibbs on April 2, 2020: A Very Partial Story of Janis May
- Queenofchaos06 on April 2, 2020: A Very Partial Story of Janis May
- Travis Gibbs on November 1, 2019: The Trouble with Civility, Part II
- Edgar on November 1, 2019: The Trouble with Civility, Part II
- Travis Gibbs on July 1, 2019: Stoical in a Time of General Sorrow?
- Edgar on July 1, 2019: Stoical in a Time of General Sorrow?
- Edgar on January 31, 2019: Mind Hack: Part Deux (see the blog dated December 10, 2016)
- Travis Gibbs on January 31, 2019: Mind Hack: Part Deux (see the blog dated December 10, 2016)
- Edgar on January 31, 2019: Mind Hack: Part Deux (see the blog dated December 10, 2016)
- Travis Gibbs on April 29, 2018: A World of Full of Intersections
- Edgar on April 29, 2018: A World of Full of Intersections
- Travis Gibbs on March 26, 2018: Part IV: Courage
- Edgar on March 26, 2018: Part IV: Courage
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- arianamromero on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on July 17, 2016: Making American Great Again? Telling it like it is?
- deborahdearest on July 17, 2016: Making American Great Again? Telling it like it is?
- Travis Gibbs on June 10, 2016: The Ratings Phenomenon
- adamgc91 on June 10, 2016: The Ratings Phenomenon
- Travis Gibbs on June 7, 2016: Who Can Use the Toilet?
- Immune2Tasers on June 7, 2016: Who Can Use the Toilet?
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- ndelao on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on June 3, 2014: God and Machine
- actions on June 3, 2014: God and Machine
- Travis Gibbs on September 9, 2013: The Not Even Ready for Bumper-Sticker Philosophy
- Travis Gibbs on More Same Ol’, Same Ol’: November 25, 2013
- Lyla on More Same Ol’, Same Ol’: November 25, 2013
- Lyla on September 9, 2013: The Not Even Ready for Bumper-Sticker Philosophy
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- Megan TLe on Contact
- Megan TLe on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- Megan TLe on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on Contact
- Travis Gibbs on Renewal: One : Chasing Our Tails
- Travis Gibbs on More Caring and Less Carrying?: Political Diversions, Part II
- v1felipe on More Caring and Less Carrying?: Political Diversions, Part II
- v1felipe on Contact
- eThoughts: Freedom, Choice, and Enlightenment on Renewal The Non-Ordinary Reference Pages
- eThoughts: Holidays, Good Will, Genuineness, Control, Awareness, Love, Grace, and Experience | Travisgibbs.com on eThoughts : We Are and the Age of Clarity
- eThoughts: Freedom, Choice, and Enlightenment | Travisgibbs.com on Renewal Six : Choice Eventually Limits Choice
- Nice on Renewal: One : Chasing Our Tails